Driving design quality

AECOM report urges Buffalo Bills to build new $1.4B stadium, not renovate

Dive Quick:

  • A new report from AECOM recommends that the NFL’s Buffalo Payments create a new stadium, alternatively than renovate their existing Highmark Stadium in Orchard Park, New York. 
  • Renovating the current stadium would cost an estimated $862 million, in comparison to the $1.35 billion approximated for a new build, in accordance to the report commissioned by Empire Condition Advancement.
  • A new stadium ought to be developed in the area of the present 1, AECOM recommended, as developing a location in downtown Buffalo would price tag around $2.1 billion or more.

Dive Insight:

The Bills, whose open up-air Highmark Stadium is almost 50 many years old, have regarded developing a new stadium for decades. The location is the fourth oldest active stadium in the NFL, at the rear of only the Chicago Bears’ Soldier Discipline, the Environmentally friendly Bay Packers’ Lambeau Area and the Kansas Town Chiefs’ Arrowhead Stadium.

The Bills’ lease expires in 2023, and in August, just before the normal NFL time commenced, the franchise submitted designs to the metropolis for a $1.4 billion, 60,000-seat stadium to be crafted by 2027, the Affiliated Push described. The submission has led to debates about exactly where that funds should arrive from. Payments owners Terry and Kim Pegula explained they are committed to shouldering part of the cost, but have not discovered how much. At minimum some of the funding would occur from taxpayer cash.

The report, released Nov. 1, urged for the building of a new location, and cautioned from renovating the recent one particular, as carrying out so could expense more than 60% of the price tag of setting up new. On top of that, renovations often have a general lifespan of 10 to 15 years, in contrast to a new stadium, which generally has a 30-12 months lifespan before requiring updates.

The better fees for making at a new, downtown internet site are attributed to the require to construct and boost leveled parking services, highway interchanges and other infrastructure upgrades.

Downtown vs. Orchard Park 

AECOM’s report believed a downtown stadium could insert supplemental $350 million in total challenge charge, not such as the possible superior price tag of relocating people and businesses. The Charges could also perhaps need to have to pay back an further $300 million to include things like a roof for the stadium to tackle orientation issues for the area. A lot of NFL stadium fields run north to south so gamers are not hindered by daylight, nevertheless it is not an specific rule. If the Bills essential to assemble their new downtown website stadium jogging east to west, they could require a dome to guard players.

Nonetheless, building on a new internet site could suggest additional cash for the city and federal government. The report researched the ancillary enhancement close to the Orchard Park internet site, estimating that a downtown site chosen by the Expenditures could likely catch the attention of advancement to an region that has not viewed any just lately. A downtown web page could supply an estimated $53 million in tax income about the upcoming 30 several years.

The report assumes that the new stadium will be open up-air and have:

  • A capacity of at the very least 60,000 seats.
  • Somewhere around 60 personal suites, each with 16 seats.
  • Approximately 60 loge boxes, every single with four to 8 seats.
  • 5,000 to 6,000 club seats, with enclosed and conditioned club areas to accommodate patrons.
  • Improved accessibility to the actively playing surface area for vehicles and products.
  • Enhanced locker rooms and services.

If the rate tag estimate is accurate, and Bills create the $1.35 billion stadium at the latest Orchard Park web page, it would come to be the 11th most expensive stadium at any time constructed, in accordance to a report from March 2021. Developing downtown with the $2.1 billion estimate would make it the 3rd most highly-priced.